Fate of Outstanding COIDA Occupational Disease Claims Following Closure of the Western Cape Provincial Medical Advisory Panel in 2008 : An audit

Background and objectives: The Western Cape Provincial Medical Advisory Panel (PMAP) was established in 2004 in terms of Section 70(1) of COIDA. A primary function was to improve the efficiency of medical assessment of occupational disease claims. The PMAP was closed by the Compensation Commissioner in 2008. This audit aimed to determine the fate of claims outstanding at the time of closure. Methods: A total of 68 claims outstanding in April 2008 were followed up by telephone; email and/or internet to determine what proportion had progressed or; if accepted; had resulted in a permanent disablement compensation payment. Results: Of the 68 claims; 31 (44) were confirmed as having progressed. Of these; payment of permanent disablement awards could be confirmed in only 15 claims (22). The remaining 56 either showed no progress or no longer had a record in the COIDA system. Those stages of the claims process that had previously been aided by PMAP functioning had deteriorated in efficiency. Conclusions: Overall; the low proportion of outstanding claims finalised and awarded is consistent with inefficiency in claims handling of occupational disease; a finding echoed by recent complaints about general Compensation Fund performance from both healthcare providers and parliamentary investigation

Disulfiram reaction in an artist exposed to solvents.

This case report describes an artist on treatment for alcoholism with disulfiram (Antabuse) who suffered chronic symptoms similar to those of a disulfiram alcohol reaction, which we attribute to his occupational exposure to products containing alcohol and other solvents. Symptoms abated with strict precautions to prevent exposure, although gradually returned over the course of months, causing him eventually to stop the medication. Medical practitioners should be aware of possible adverse interactions between occupational solvent exposures and disulfiram.

Chronic airflow obstruction and respiratory symptoms following tuberculosis: a review of South African studies.

BACKGROUND: There is renewed interest in the chronic respiratory sequelae of pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB), particularly chronic airflow limitation. A number of South African epidemiological studies have been published, which, although not specifically designed to examine this association, provide useful data on the nature of the relationship. OBJECTIVE: To review population-based and occupational studies conducted in South Africa that provide estimates of the association between PTB, chronic symptoms and lung function loss. RESULTS: Two general population and a number of occupational studies were included. Most were able to control for likely confounders. Chronic chest symptoms and lung function loss were consistently associated with PTB, whether measured by self-report or prospectively in cohort studies. Odds ratios (ORs) were higher for chronic bronchitis (range 1.5-7.2) than for asthma (range 0.7-2.2). For spirometrically defined chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, the OR range was 2.6-8.9, depending on definition. Combined obstructive/restrictive lung function loss was the most common functional outcome, with a net obstructive effect. The association of past TB with non-specific bronchial hyperresponsiveness was equivocal. CONCLUSION: These studies add to the evidence of a strong association between PTB, even if treated, and subsequent airflow obstruction as well as restrictive loss. Unanswered questions include extent of recovery over time, effect modification by smoking and other cofactors, and degree of reversibility by treatment.

Lung function loss in relation to silica dust exposure in South African gold miners.

OBJECTIVE: To estimate exposure-response relationships between respirable dust, respirable quartz and lung function loss in black South African gold miners. METHODS: 520 mineworkers aged >37 years were enrolled in a cross-sectional study. Gravimetric dust measurements were used to calculate cumulative respirable dust and quartz exposures. Excess lung function loss was defined as predicted minus observed forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV(1)) and forced vital capacity (FVC). The association between excess loss and exposure was estimated, adjusting for smoking, tuberculosis and silicosis. RESULTS: Mean service length was 21.8 years, mean respirable dust 0.37 mg/m(3) and mean respirable quartz 0.053 mg/m(3). After adjustment, 1 mg-yr/m(3) increase in cumulative respirable dust exposure was associated with 18.7 ml mean excess loss in FVC [95% confidence interval (CI) 0.3, 37.1] and 16.2 ml in FEV1 (95% CI -0.3, 32.6). Mean excess loss with silicosis was 224.1 ml in FEV1 and 123.6 ml in FVC; with tuberculosis 347.4 ml in FEV1 and 264.3 ml in FVC. CONCLUSION: Despite a healthy worker effect, lung function loss was demonstrable whether due to silicosis, tuberculosis or an independent effect of dust. A miner working at a respirable dust intensity of 0.37 mg/m(3) for 30 years would lose on average an additional 208 ml in FVC (95% CI 3, 412) in the absence of other disease, an impact greater than that of silicosis and comparable to that of tuberculosis. Improved dust control on the South African gold mines would reduce the risk of silicosis, tuberculosis and lung function impairment.

Excess lung function decline in gold miners following pulmonary tuberculosis.

BACKGROUND: Few if any studies of the association between pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) and lung function loss have had access to premorbid lung function values. METHODS: Using a retrospective cohort design, the study recruited employed South African gold miners who had undergone a pulmonary function test (PFT) between January 1995 and August 1996. The 'exposed' group comprised 185 miners treated for pulmonary TB after the initial PFT and the 'unexposed' group comprised 185 age-matched miners without TB. All participants had a follow-up PFT between April and June 2000. The outcome of interest was decline in lung function during the follow-up period as measured by forced vital capacity (FVC) and forced expiratory volume in 1 s(FEV(1)). RESULTS: After controlling for age, height, baseline lung function, silicosis, years of employment, smoking and other respiratory diagnoses, pulmonary TB during the follow-up period was associated with a mean excess loss of 40.3 ml/year in FEV(1) (95% CI 25.4 to 55.1) and 42.7 ml/year in FVC (95% CI 27.0 to 58.5). Lung function loss was greater among those with more severe or later clinical presentation of TB. Breathlessness was twice as common among TB cases (OR 2.20, 95% CI 1.18 to 4.11). CONCLUSION: There is a need for greater clinical recognition of the long-term respiratory consequences of treated pulmonary TB. Early detection of TB would help to reduce these sequelae and remains a priority, particularly in a workforce already subject to silica dust disease. However, strategies such as dust control, worker education about TB and dust and TB preventive therapy are also needed to avert the disease itself.

Tuberculosis and silica exposure in South African gold miners.

AIMS: To examine the effect of silica exposure, in the absence of silicosis, on the prevalence of pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB), which is epidemic among South African gold miners. METHODS: Cross-sectional study of 520 gold miners over 37 years of age. Length of service, and cumulative and average dust and quartz exposure indices were derived for each miner. Chest radiographs were read for PTB by two NIOSH "B" readers. PTB was defined as a self-reported history of PTB or PTB on chest radiograph. Logistic regression was used to adjust for age, smoking, and silicosis. PTB effects of different exposure metrics for silica, scaled on their interquartile range (IQR), were compared. RESULTS: Means (ranges) were: age 46.7 (37.1-59.9) years; length of service 21.8 (6.3-34.5) years; average intensity of respirable quartz 0.053 (0-0.095) mg/m3. PTB prevalence was 19.4% (95% CI 16.0 to 22.8) on history alone, and 35.2% (95% CI 31.1 to 39.3) on history or on chest radiograph. Length of service was poorly predictive of PTB, while all exposure indices which included dust or quartz yielded prevalence odds ratios (PORs) of approximately 1.4 (95% CI approximately 1.1 to 1.8) for changes of one interquartile range in exposure. Controlling for silicosis--by adjustment or restriction--did not modify these results. Drillers and winch operators had the highest PTB prevalences and the highest dust and silica exposures. CONCLUSION: Older in-service gold miners in South Africa have a high prevalence of PTB, which is significantly associated with dust and silica exposure, even in the absence of silicosis. Limitations include a survivor workforce and the use of cumulative exposures based on current exposures. Dust control is an important component in control of the PTB epidemic in South African gold mines.

Wheeze, asthma diagnosis and medication use: a national adult survey in a developing country.

BACKGROUND: As relatively little is known about adult wheeze and asthma in developing countries, this study aimed to determine the predictors of wheeze, asthma diagnosis, and current treatment in a national survey of South African adults. METHODS: A stratified national probability sample of households was drawn and all adults (>14 years) in the selected households were interviewed. Outcomes of interest were recent wheeze, asthma diagnosis, and current use of asthma medication. Predictors of interest were sex, age, household asset index, education, racial group, urban residence, medical insurance, domestic exposure to smoky fuels, occupational exposure, smoking, body mass index, and past tuberculosis. RESULTS: A total of 5671 men and 8155 women were studied. Although recent wheeze was reported by 14.4% of men and 17.6% of women and asthma diagnosis by 3.7% of men and 3.8% of women, women were less likely than men to be on current treatment (OR 0.6; 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.5 to 0.8). A history of tuberculosis was an independent predictor of both recent wheeze (OR 3.4; 95% CI 2.5 to 4.7) and asthma diagnosis (OR 2.2; 95% CI 1.5 to 3.2), as was occupational exposure (wheeze: OR 1.8; 95% CI 1.5 to 2.0; asthma diagnosis: OR 1.9; 95% CI 1.4 to 2.4). Smoking was associated with wheeze but not asthma diagnosis. Obesity showed an association with wheeze only in younger women. Both wheeze and asthma diagnosis were more prevalent in those with less education but had no association with the asset index. Independently, having medical insurance was associated with a higher prevalence of diagnosis. CONCLUSIONS: Some of the findings may be to due to reporting bias and heterogeneity of the categories wheeze and asthma diagnosis, which may overlap with post tuberculous airways obstruction and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease due to smoking and occupational exposures. The results underline the importance of controlling tuberculosis and occupational exposures as well as smoking in reducing chronic respiratory morbidity. Validation of the asthma questionnaire in this setting and research into the pathophysiology of post tuberculous airways obstruction are also needed.

Socioeconomic status and prevalence of allergic rhinitis and atopic eczema symptoms in young adolescents.

Environmental factors are known to influence the development of allergic rhinitis and atopic eczema in genetically susceptible individuals. Socioeconomic status (SES) may be an important indicator of risk for these conditions. The International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood (ISAAC) Phase 1 written questionnaire was used to determine the prevalence and severity of allergic rhinoconjunctivitis and atopic eczema symptoms in 4947 pupils aged 13-14 years attending 30 schools in socioeconomically diverse areas of Cape Town. Home addresses were used to stratify participants into five SES bands. Relationships between symptom prevalence and severity, and SES, recent urbanization and upward socioeconomic mobility were examined. Logistic regression was used to generate odds ratios (OR) and 95% confidence intervals (CI) in order to assess overall trends by SES. The prevalences of self-reported allergic rhinitis symptoms and recurrent itchy rash in the past year were 33.2% and 11.9% respectively. Girls had a significantly higher prevalence of all symptoms than boys. The prevalence of allergic rhinitis symptoms increased from lowest to highest SES (overall OR for rhinitis symptoms in past year = 1.16, 95% CI 1.11-1.21). There was no significant trend in reported eczema symptoms by SES other than for the question, 'Have you ever had eczema' (OR = 0.88, 95% CI 0.83-0.93). Longer period of urbanization was weakly associated only with recurrent itchy skin rash (OR = 1.05, 95% CI 1.01-1.09). 'Socially mobile' pupils, i.e. those resident in the lowest SES areas but attending highest SES schools showed significantly higher prevalences of eczema and some rhinitis symptoms than pupils attending lowest SES schools. These findings may reflect differences in reporting related to language, culture and access to medical care rather than real differences in prevalence.

Predictors of chronic bronchitis in South African adults.

SETTING: National household survey of adults in South Africa, a middle income country. OBJECTIVE: To determine the prevalence and predictors of chronic bronchitis. DESIGN: A stratified national probability sample of households was selected. All adults in the selected households were interviewed. Chronic bronchitis was defined as chronic productive cough. Socio-demographic predictors were wealth, education, race, age and urban residence. Personal and exposure variables included history of tuberculosis, domestic exposure to smoky fuels, occupational exposures, smoking and body mass index. RESULTS: The overall prevalence of chronic bronchitis was 2.3% in men and 2.8% in women. The strongest predictor of chronic bronchitis was a history of tuberculosis (men, odds ratio [OR] 4.9; 95% confidence interval [CI] 2.6-9.2; women, OR 6.6; 95%CI 3.7-11.9). Other risk factors were smoking, occupational exposure (in men), domestic exposure to smoky fuel (in women) and (in univariate analysis only) being underweight. Wealth and particularly education were protective. CONCLUSION: The pattern of chronic bronchitis in South Africa suggests a combination of risk factors that includes not only smoking but also tuberculosis, occupational exposures in men and domestic fuel exposure in women. Control of these risk factors requires public health action across a broad front. The protective role of education requires elucidation.

Body mass index and the risk of asthma in adults.

Asthma and obesity are both chronic conditions and their prevalences have risen in affluent societies. A positive association between asthma and being overweight or obese has been reported in children and women, but associations in men are less clearly described. The objective of this study was to explore the association between body mass index (BMI) and asthma in men and women of diverse ethnic and socioeconomic background living in New York State, USA. In this study, we analyzed cross-sectional data on 5524 subjects aged 18 years and older who were interviewed by telephone in the 1996 and 1997 New York State Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System. Asthma (doctor-diagnosed), and weight and height were self-reported. BMI (kg/m2) was used as a measure of adiposity. Weighted logistic regression analysis, with stratification by gender and age, was used to examine the relationship between asthma prevalence and BMI, adjusting for race/ethnicity, education, health insurance, time since last physical examination, physical activity and smoking status. The results showed that the prevalence of asthma was 4.6% (CI: 3.6-5.5%) among men and 8.1% (CI: 7.1-9.1%) among women. In women, the prevalence of asthma was significantly increased in those with a BMI 25 kg/m2 or higher (BMI 25-27.5: OR = 1.76, 95% CI: 1.06-2.94; BMI 27.5-29.9: OR = 2.45, 95% CI: 1.41-4.25; BMI > or = 30: OR = 2.67, 95% CI: 1.66-4.29) when compared to the reference category (BMI: 22-24.9 kg/m2). In men, the prevalence of asthma was increased in the lowest weight category, BMI < 22 kg/m2 (OR = 3.05, 95% CI: 1.37-6.78) and in the highest category, BMI > or = 30 kg/m2 (OR = 2.92, 95% CI: 1.39-6.14). This U-shaped association persisted when restricting the analysis to men who had never smoked and was more pronounced for those between 18 and 49 years of age. In conclusion, this cross-sectional study showed that men and women differ significantly in the association between BMI and asthma prevalence only with respect to the lowest weight category. While women had a monotonic association, men showed a U-shaped relationship, indicating that both extremes of weight are associated with a higher prevalence of asthma.

Socioeconomic deprivation and asthma prevalence and severity in young adolescents.

This study used the international study of asthma and allergies in childhood (ISAAC) to investigate the association between asthma and socioeconomic deprivation among young adolescents in Cape Town, South Africa. The completed ISAAC written and video questionnaires of 4,706 13-14-yr-old school pupils were used. The prevalence of asthma symptoms was analysed by a local index of socioeconomic deprivation, based on residential location and defined on a 10-category scale from least to most deprived. Linear trends were examined visually and the prevalence odds ratio was used to summarize overall trends. In general, the least socioeconomically deprived pupils reported higher prevalences of asthma symptoms "ever" and "in the last 12 months". In contrast, the most socioeconomically deprived pupils reported higher asthma-symptom occurrence monthly or more frequently in the previous 12 months. A subgroup of pupils from low-income areas commuting to better-off schools showed the highest symptom prevalences. The findings are consistent with a model in which an increase in the incidence of asthma is driven by factors associated with improved social circumstances, whereas severity is determined by factors associated with poverty. The impact of social mobility on asthma, including reporting of symptoms, deserves closer study.

Repeatability of tibia lead measurement by X-Ray fluorescence in a battery-making workforce.

The purpose of this study was to remeasure in vivo tibia lead levels in a lead-acid battery manufacturing workforce measured in a previous survey and believed to be unrealistically high. Tibia lead levels were measured by K-shell X-ray fluorescence (XRF) spectroscopy in a stratified random sample (n=40) of the original study group (n=381). The repeat survey showed much lower tibia lead levels (median=54.3 microg lead/g bone mineral, compared to 217.9 microg lead/g bone mineral, n=40). Tibia lead levels were significantly correlated with duration of occupational exposure, zinc protoporphyrin levels, and cumulative blood lead index, but not with current blood lead levels. Thirty-eight of the 40 subjects underwent two consecutive tibia lead measurements to assess the test-retest repeatability of the XRF tibia lead measurement technique. The intraclass correlation coefficient between repeated measurements was 0.926 (P=0.0001). Three measurement pairs differed by more than 20 microg/g. There was no fixed or proportional bias between the two sets of measurements. We conclude that the technique offers a highly repeatable measurement of tibia bone lead. However, care needs to be taken to avoid contamination when performing measurements on active lead workers.

Notification of occupational diseases by general practitioners in the Western Cape.

BACKGROUND: Notification of occupational diseases to the Department of Labour (and in limited situations to other agencies) is an important aspect of surveillance and planning for interventions as well as compensation. A survey of general practitioners (GPs) was conducted to assess their knowledge and practice with regard to reporting of occupational diseases. DESIGN: Descriptive telephonic survey. SETTING: Independent general practices in the Western Cape. PARTICIPANTS: One hundred and forty GPs were randomly selected from a provincial sampling frame of 1,000 GPs. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Knowledge of notification procedures for occupational diseases, and problems encountered with the reporting system. RESULTS: Of a total of 109 GPs interviewed, 75% had diagnosed more than one case of occupational disease in the last 6 months. Twenty-four per cent of the total (95% confidence interval (CI) 16-32%) indicated that they were aware of the notification requirements, and 5% (95% CI 0.8-9%) knew the appropriate legislation. Only one GP notified the appropriate authority once the diagnosis was made. Factors influencing their reporting practice included lack of guidelines for diagnosis of common work-related conditions, lack of information regarding referral channels, problems with communicating with the patient and employer, and poor knowledge of the reporting process itself. Lack of motivation as a result of poor feedback on cases reported and the labour-intensive administration required, were also cited as factors. CONCLUSION: Although the majority of GPs diagnose occupational diseases, knowledge and practice regarding notification are poor. Recommendations to overcome obstacles to notification include a simplified, uniform notification system, adequate training and support of GPs, and timeous feedback to GPs.

Possible occupational asthma among adults presenting with acute asthma.

BACKGROUND: Little is known about the risk of occupational asthma or its causative agents in South Africa. The objective of this study was to determine the proportion of adult asthmatics whose asthma may be occupational, and the main agents or occupations involved. DESIGN AND SETTING: A descriptive surveillance study of adult patients presenting with acute asthma to the casualty units of two large public hospitals in Cape Town. METHODS: A brief questionnaire was completed by the casualty staff for a sample of 140 adult asthmatic patients. Respondents were classified as having possible occupational asthma on the basis of adult-onset asthma, exposure at time of onset to a known or suspected cause of occupational asthma, and symptoms that improved away from work. RESULTS: Eighteen patients (12.9%, 95% confidence interval (CI) 7.8-19.6%) met the criteria for occupational asthma. The main occupational categories in this group were spray painters (4 patients) and domestic workers (4 patients), with cleaning agents, dyes and paints being the most commonly reported exposures. A total of 36 patients (25.7%, 95% CI 18.7-33.7%) reported work aggravation of their asthma. CONCLUSIONS: A clinically significant proportion of adult-onset asthmatics, men and women, may have occupational causation, while an even larger proportion may have occupational aggravation. Since early intervention favourably influences prognosis in occupational asthma, all practitioners dealing with adult asthmatics should explore occupational factors.

Knowledge, attitudes, and practices of parents of asthmatic children in Cape Town.

To obtain information useful to asthma care in a relatively poor, high asthma prevalence population, a focus group study was undertaken with 72 parents of children with asthma or recurrent wheezing. There was a reasonable level of understanding of the causes of asthma, although variable acceptance of the diagnosis. Willingness to undertake home management of acute episodes and environmental control measures was high. Reported treatment was characterized by reliance on syrups, use of home remedies, resistance to inhaled therapy, and relatively low compliance with prescribed treatment. There was agreement on the poor level of service offered by doctors and public sector clinics. Asthma education in this population needs to build on what parents know and accept, but stress the relative safety of inhaled therapy, the need for maintenance therapy, and the value of pre-exercise prophylaxis, house dust mite control, and smoking cessation. There is an urgent need to improve the quality of asthma care provided by public sector clinics.

Environmental tobacco smoke exposure in children: household and community determinants.

To determine the most important sources of environmental tobacco smoke exposure to young children, the authors studied the associations among urinary cotinine, reported household smoking habits, and socioeconomic variables in 575 schoolchildren aged 6-11 y. The school children were among a population of prodigious smokers in Cape Town, South Africa. Eighty percent of the children were exposed to environmental tobacco smoke. Maternal smoking, which was adjusted for creatinine, accounted for 21.8% of the variation in urinary cotinine--more than all other sources combined. The male parent and other household smokers accounted for 12.7% of the variation, and socioeconomic indicators explained an additional 4.8%. By defining the ecological variable of smoking prevalence per school, the authors estimated a "community" contribution of 3.3%. The relative importance of different sources of smoke should be taken into account in the prevention of environmental tobacco smoke exposure in young children. Most importantly, of all the sources of environmental tobacco smoke, mothers' smoking habits had the greatest impact on exposure to children.

Underrecognition and undertreatment of asthma in Cape Town primary school children.

BACKGROUND: In view of the high local prevalence of asthma, the extent of recognition and appropriate management of childhood asthma was studied in a large suburban area of Cape Town. DESIGN: Cross-sectional study based on random community sample of schools. METHOD: 1,955 parents of sub B pupils from 16 schools completed a questionnaire, followed by: (i) an interview of the parents of 348 symptomatic children; and (ii) bronchial responsiveness testing on 254 children. The final case group consisted of 242 children with reported asthma or multiple asthma symptoms on both questionnaires. Children in whom asthma was acknowledged were compared with those in whom it was not. RESULTS: Overall, any past or current ('ever') asthma was acknowledged by respondents in only 53% of the children, and current asthma in only 37.1%. While most children had received treatment in the previous 12 months, 66.1% of the recognised group were on current treatment (23.2% on daily treatment), compared with 37% of the unrecognised group (3% daily). Salbutamol and theophylline syrups were the most common types of medication, while inhalers and anti-inflammatory medications were underused. Only a minority of parents reported the child ever having used a peak flow meter, or volunteered knowledge of preventive measures. Current treatment, and to a lesser degree recognition of asthma by parents, were more common among children on medical aid and of higher socio-economic status. CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest that ways need to be found: (i) to increase the use of current asthma treatment guidelines by practitioners; (ii) to provide access to comprehensive care by children not on medical aid; and (iii) to improve education of parents in home management measures such as severity assessment and avoidance of smoking, allergen and dietary triggers.

Semen quality and fertility of men employed in a South African lead acid battery plant.

Previous studies of the associations of measures of occupational lead exposure with measures of semen quality and infertility among male workers have produced conflicting results. The current study was undertaken to examine these associations among a population of workers with a broad range of measures of current and historical lead exposure. Ninety-seven lead-exposed workers from a South African lead acid battery facility provided semen samples that were analyzed for sperm density, sperm count, sperm motility, sperm morphology, and presence of antisperm antibodies. Questionnaire data were collected for reported histories of sub- or infertility. Current blood leads ranged from 28 to 93 micrograms/dl. Semen lead ranged from 1 to 87 micrograms/dl. Reasonably consistent and significant associations were found between an increased percentage of sperm with abnormal morphology and higher measures of current blood lead, cumulative blood lead, and duration of exposure. An increased percent of immotile sperm was associated only with zinc protoporphyrin (ZPP) among the lead exposure measures. There were no associations of sperm density or sperm count with any of the lead exposure measures. A weak association of increased percent of sperm with antisperm antibodies with increased semen lead was present. There were no consistent associations of measures of lead exposure with measures of fertility or procreativity. This study, while supporting the association of lead exposure with increased risk of abnormal sperm morphology seen in some previous studies, does not lend support to previously reported associations of sperm density or count or infertility with measures of lead exposure. However, the relatively high range of current blood leads, high prevalence of abnormalities in semen quality, and the lack of a control population, suggest that these negative findings should be interpreted with caution.

Regression of polyvinylchloride polymer pneumoconiosis.

A 35 year old man heavily exposed to polyvinylchloride (PVC) polymer dust developed dyspnoea and a mild restrictive lung disorder consistent with PVC pneumoconiosis. Clinical and radiological abnormalities cleared on removal from exposure, suggesting that in its early stages PVC pneumoconiosis is reversible.